'Comparison of the Odyssey and O Brother, Where Art Thou?>\r'

'Platt Pre AP English 9 5/9/2012 O Brother, This is Not yet Close To the Odyssey E genuinely wizard loves to immerse themselves into a salient and extraordinary paper with evil monsters, stomach aces, and the dire will to survive. It on the wholeows you to escape your troubles and experience you to a new and exiting please with separately and perpetuallyy second. However, there are around stories that merely do not stupefy the essence of breathtaking adventure. The movie O Brother, Where Art Thou? created by the comedic police squad of Ethan and Joel Coen, simply does not capture the suspicious classic fiction.O Brother, Where Art Thou? Is the boastful screen remake of Homers epic poesy, â€Å"The Odyssey”. This archetype story is most the adventure of Odysseus as he escapes his sevener year durance from the goddess Calypso. This Epic hero battles numerous monsters on his desperate attempt to return family to his married woman genus genus Penelope, whom he meets again in a heartfelt reuniting. However, in the re-make film, a man named Ulysseus is a prison escapee that is desperate to keep his married woman, cent, from marrying another man, lying and imposition his way to reach his goal.The Coen brothers lose created such a disappointing excuse for capturing a real hero and his adventures to be reunited with his rightful(a) love. It is near idiotic. The story is so wooly and distracted by the gratuitous details, and it abandons the unbent meaning of the heartwarming story. When a individual imagines the heartfelt reuniting of a husband and married woman after being separated for seven painstakingly long years, you dream of the ease and joy of the meeting. The story of â€Å"Penelope” in â€Å"The Odyssey” by Homer reflects this idea exquisitely. The Coen brothers O Brother, Where Art Thou?Has a reasonably correspondent take on the story of Penelope. No matter the specific and well shown facts that the epic verse form is much greater than the comedic film. The married woman of Odysseus in the epic poem is named Penelope, and extremely similar to the name of Ulysseuss wife, centime. In the movie, they were separated by the federal bonds of Everett Ulysseus, and the time it excessivelyk to return back home. in addition similar, the archetype hero Odysseus was kept from his wife Penelope by his impris superstarr Calypso for many an(prenominal) years, and the additional years of fighting for his smell to return home to her.Also, in the poem, Odysseus was in his hometown while he saw his wife for the first time after all of those years. So was the place that Ulysseus was reunited with Penny in the film. There are some similarities amidst the film and the epic poem, but it is tranquillize believable that the similarities can not be compared to the shining differences. The poem is such an inspirational and heartfelt spectacle, it makes the film appear futile and no deep emotion winding with it. There are extremely few similarities, but there are for sure no shortage of differences between these dickens stories.Penelope is such a heartwarming, in insight part of the poem where odysseus meets his wife in one brass again. That is how it takes place in the epic poem anyway. In the film, it is the short, awkward moment of Ulysseus and his wife meeting again, to find out that Penny has completely and totally moved on. Also, Odysseus, in the poem, was disguised as a beggar, and his wife Penelope, had no idea who he genuinely was. She tells him of the whole in her heart ever since her love disappeared, and he knowingly calm her that her love would return.However, in the film, Ulysseus angrily approached Penny and demanded why she would ever lie to their children nearly his death. Penny went on to describe about how she had not missed him one bit. A complete and utter opposite of how the poems Penelope had felt. In â€Å"The Odyssey” Penelope had man y, many suitors that she would neer accept for marriage. They ate her out of domiciliate and home, practically destroyed her life, tho devising her want Odysseus even much. All too differently, in the film, Penny had but one suitor, who she was set to marry that weekend, with no remorse.Ulysseus didn’t even disguise himself to her. This entire reenactment was twain rude and uncaring. It showed no relief in the fact the hero of the story survived and was so heroic that he beat the odds. Indeed, it was very disappointing of a story. Most movies have a change to a story to emphasize or make it clearer to the viewers. However, it is intelligibly disappointing when the changes to the story are unnecessary. Everyone has perceive of the saying â€Å"the book was better than the movie. ” This is the case for the film translation of â€Å"The Odyssey”.The scene of Penelope is once of those specific scenes where it would be more reasonable to make it more similar to the original. However, it did work for a more comedic diagram line. It exemplified crude humor and a neglect of true deep emotions. It is exactly what the Coen brothers hypothesise when it comes to movie creating. horizontal though the changes are completely pointless, it adds a somewhat knowledge to the all-around immature story. But it in addition creates this unloving relationship between the hero and his love.This relationship is full of jealousy and unneeded feuding. It may do something for the movie, yet it is simply not enough to make it enjoyable. When a person sits down with a adept book or a coil of popcorn waiting for a movie, it is false that there will be a thrilling, capturing story. Unfortunately, the film, O Brother, Where Art Thou? , enjoin by the team of brothers, Ethan and Joel Coen, is not one such story as fit(p) by the disappointing and idiotic differences to the original epic poem â€Å"The Odyssey”.The differences in the two were blaring ly overwhelming in comparison to the similarities. In this case, the differences did not help in write this incredible tale of â€Å"The Odyssey”. Even in the most deep, picturesque scenes such as Penelope, there was a distinct hardship by the creators of the film. Penelope called for such dawdle and heart-lifting emotion, the crude joke of it was almost criminal. Even if the film was taken in a more serious direction, it would have only scraped the surface of such a beautiful epic poem.\r\n'